Heat Pump VS A Furnace For Heating Your Home

In our area of Southwest Virginia, heating systems are an integral part of the home. They keep your home warm and comfortable, and also have a direct impact on your energy bills for half of the year. Deciding what kind of HVAC system you are going to choose to heat your home is important. In our area, heat pumps and furnaces are two of the most popular heating systems for home and businesses.
We’ve been working in the area for 15+ years, installing furnaces and heat pumps alike. We know not every home is the same, and each one has its own unique needs. In this article, we’re going to talk about the difference between using a furnace to heat your home and a heat pump.
If you think your home is due for a comfort upgrade, be it heating or cooling, give us a call at (276) 690-9222, or contact us online. Our experts would be happy to help you out with your home comfort needs!
How A Heat Pump Works VS How A Furnace Works
As we said, in our area of Virginia, both heat pumps and furnaces are both very popular. They are both reliable systems that can keep a home comfortable in our climate. It gets cold here, but it’s not the arctic, and both systems are suited to handle the cold we experience.
Here is how each system works:
How A Furnace Works
A furnace generates heat by burning fuel (most commonly natural gas or propane) or by using electricity. More commonly, we see fuel burning furnaces. Once heat is created, a blower fan pushes that warm air through your ductwork and into each room of your home. We have a lot of gas and oil burning furnaces in our area of Virginia and Tennessee.
Key points about furnaces:
- Produce heat directly
- Typically run on natural gas, propane, oil, or electricity
- Can deliver very hot air quickly
Furnaces are especially effective during very cold weather because their heat output does not depend on outdoor temperatures, like a heat pump does. These systems generate their own heat, which can be a benefit, and also a drawback in some cases. More on that later. Still, this ability to generate heat independently makes for quick, dependable heating.
How A Heat Pump Works
A heat pump works differently than a furnace. Instead of creating heat, a heat pump moves heat. Even when it’s cold outside, there is still heat energy in the air. A heat pump pulls that heat from outside and transfers it indoors. In the summer, the process reverses, allowing the system to cool your home.
Key points about heat pumps:
- Transfer heat instead of generating it
- Run primarily on electricity
- Provide both heating and cooling
- Extremely energy efficient in mild to moderate climates
Modern cold-climate heat pumps are well-suited for Southwest Virginia and can operate efficiently even when outdoor temperatures drop into the teens. In the past, heat pumps had a hard time handling frigid temperatures, and wouldn’t be able to produce enough heat to keep certain climates comfortable. Today, the advanced heat pump technology accommodates weather like the kind we see here in Virginia and Tennessee.
The Benefits Of A Furnace
Furnaces have been a trusted heating solution for decades, and for good reason. The fact that these systems don’t depend on sourcing heat from the cold outside gives them a quicker ability to heat, and when the temps really drop, this dependable heating may be a comfort compared to heat pumps.
Benefits include:
- Strong, consistent heat during cold snaps
- Long lifespan with proper maintenance
- Ideal for homes with natural gas access
- Familiar technology many homeowners are comfortable with
If you want powerful heat that feels warm right away—especially during the coldest winter nights—a furnace can be a great choice.
Drawbacks Of A Furnace
A furnace is dependable, but not always perfect. Here are some of the cons to using a furnace:
- Produces dangerous harmful gases
- Can only heat, not cool
- Depend on gas/oil prices for your heating bills
- Less environmentally friendly
- Not normally as energy efficient as a heat pump
Benefits Of A Heat Pump
Heat pumps have become increasingly popular as technology has improved and energy costs have changed. In fact, many energy providers, heat pump manufacturers, and even government programs will provide financial incentives when you install a heat pump for your home.
Benefits include:
- Lower monthly energy costs for many homes
- One system for heating and cooling
- High efficiency and lower environmental impact
- Eligible for utility rebates and federal tax credits
- Great option for homes without gas service
- Ductless heat pumps great for homes with no ductwork
For homeowners looking to reduce energy usage and future-proof their home, heat pumps are often an excellent investment. These systems are environmentally friendly, and energy efficient. They’ve become the preferred choice to install for our team here at Complete Comfort in the past 5 years.
Read More: Replacing A Heat Pump In Damascus, VA
Which System Is Best For Your Home?
Every home is unique, and not every system may be perfect for every home. The best heating system depends on several factors:
- Your home’s size and insulation
- Whether natural gas is available
- Your comfort preferences
- Energy costs in your area
- Budget and long-term goals
In many cases, we recommend a heat pump. The energy savings and flexibility to provide both heating and cooling are huge benefits that most of our customers prefer. We also install dual-fuel systems, which pair a heat pump with a furnace—giving you efficiency during mild weather and powerful heat when temperatures drop.
We’ve been serving Southwest Virginia for over 15 years, and we are starting to work in Northeastern Tennessee as well. We know that no two homes are the same, and make sure that our customers are taken care of individually. If you’re considering upgrading your heating system or replacing an older unit, we’d be happy to help you explore your options.
Call us at (276) 690-9222 or contact us online to schedule a consultation. Our comfort experts will help you choose the system that’s right for your home!


One newer and more unique ways of improving your home comfort and saving energy is by
As summer winds down here in Southwest Virginia, it’s the perfect time to make sure your home is ready for the change in seasons. At
Changing your HVAC filter is one of the simplest—and most important—tasks you can perform on your own. After months of running your air conditioner, your filter fills up with dust, pollen, and any other airborne irritants that pass through. We recommend that you change the filter once every 1-3 months. At the end of the summer is a perfect time to do it.
Deciding to upgrade your HVAC system is a big decision. A new HVAC system is a large investment, and one that impacts not only your wallet, but also your home comfort and energy bills for the next decade.
The owners of this lovely older Federal style home in Marion VA had a 25 year old HVAC system that was consistently needing repairs. As tends to happen, when the hot weather hit, the system started working overtime, and the stress led to more break-downs. The homeowner was an elderly woman and her son was helping her maintain the property, but needed to do so from his home out of state. That made getting prompt and courteous service important as well. The frequent breakdowns were causing a lot of stress, and were becoming more than just inconvenient.
Once the family decided on the right system for the home, the next concern was installation. The team from Complete Comfort made sure to let the homeowner know when we would be there, what to expect, and how long the job would take. Here at Complete Comfort, we take pride in caring for your home like it was our own, and we know having a whole crew in your home can be stressful, especially when it’s hot weather and a speedy replacement is important. We worked to remove the old system and install the new Trane heating and air conditioning system quickly and efficiently, completing the job in one day, to get the home back to comfort as quickly as possible.
At Complete Comfort, many of our team have lived in this community for our whole lives. That means we’re friends and neighbors, and take the responsibility that goes with that seriously. So when one of the owner’s former teachers called and became a customer, we were pretty excited! After all, no one is perfect in school, and if your teacher trusts you with their home and HVAC system, it’s like bringing home a gold star on your report card all over again.
Most people take their HVAC system for granted until it doesn’t operate. It sits there quietly doing its job, day in and day out, until something goes wrong, and then it can be a real problem. And just like people, systems tend to develop problems when they are under stress- when we have a patch of really hot or really cold weather- this can send aging systems into overdrive and they can break down.
Routine maintenance for your HVAC system is crucial to getting the most out of your heating and cooling units. Unfortunately for this homeowner in Marion, VA, it wasn’t routine maintenance like usual. Instead they ended up needing to replace their HVAC system, something they knew it was about time to do.
After looking at a few options, these homeowners decided to install a new Trane
We also installed a new Generac Generator while we upgraded the HVAC system. They were sick of losing power, especially after dealing with the hurricane so recently. They decided to install a whole home generator, something we install every week for homes and businesses in our area.
Here at Complete Comfort, we’re dedicated to keeping your family warm and comfortable all winter long. We know many people out there have rooms in their home that are often too hot or too cold- no matter where you set your thermostat, some rooms, due to their location, number of windows, or distance from the heat source, just end up a little colder- sometimes too cold for comfort- from the rest of the home.
We recently replaced an HVAC system in Glade Spring, VA with a brand new Trane
Luckily for us and the homeowner, there was already ductwork installed from the previous HVAC system. We inspected it to make sure it was still in good working order, and then removed the old system. We installed the new Trane Heat Pump in a single day. The process is one we are familiar with, and fortunately one that was quick and easy for our installation team!
One of the most energy efficient and best ways to keep your home or business comfortable is with a heat pump. Not only do they heat your home in the winter, but they also have the ability to cool your home in the summer. In Bristol, VA and the surrounding areas, heat pumps are one of the most popular ways to keep a home or business comfortable all year long.
Absolutely, heat pumps are designed for year-round use. In the winter, they provide efficient heating by extracting heat from the outside air—even in cold temperatures—and transferring it indoors. During the summer months, the process is reversed to cool your home by removing indoor heat and releasing it outside.